Master of Private Law (Russian School of Private Law),
Advocate of the Bar Association “Jurproject”

DOI: 10.24031/1992-2043-2019-19-3-53-95

This article is devoted to the problem of recognizing three-dimensional volumes of space as
real estate objects, as well as ways to reflect the 3D situations in the cadastre and registry.
The first part of the article is devoted to the definition of a 3D situation, as well as the current
practice of regulating 3D situations in Russia and abroad. The second part contains an
analysis of possible ways for the development of Russian legislation in the field of registration
of rights to three-dimensional volumes of space and the regulation of 3D situations.

Keywords: 3D cadaster; real property; land plot; unified real property unit.


Бевзенко Р.С. Земельный участок с постройками на нем: введение в россий-
ское право недвижимости [Электронное издание] [Bevzenko R.S. Plot of Land with
Buildings on It: An Introduction to Russian Real Estate Law [Electronic Edition]] (in
Russian). Moscow: M-Logos, 2017.
Бевзенко Р.С. Что такое недвижимая вещь? Комментарий к определению
Судебной коллегии по экономическим спорам ВС РФ от 30.09.2015 № 303-
ЭС15-5520 (дело «Омега Лайн») [Bevzenko R.S. What Is an Immovable Thing?
Commentary to the Determination of the Judicial Board on Economic Disputes of
the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 30 September 2015 No. 303-ES15-
5520 (Omega Line Case)] (in Russian) // Bulletin of Economic Justice of the Russian
Federation. 2015. No. 12.
Василишин И.И., Буднецкий Н.С. Реализация модели единого объекта
недвижимости в российском и германском гражданском обороте [Vasilishin I.I.,
Budnetsky N.S. Realization of the Model of a Sole Property Unit in the Russian
and German Civil Turnover] (in Russian) // International Public and Private Law.
2016. No. 1.
Ваутерс Х.Й., Елизарова Г.Ю. и др. Создание модели трехмерного кадастра
недвижимости в России. G2G10/RF/9/1. Заключительный отчет [Wouters H.J.,
Elizarova G.Yu. et al. Creating a Model of Three-Dimensional Real Estate Cadastre
in Russia. G2G10/RF/9/1. Final Report] (in Russian). Moscow, 2012.
Витрянский В.В. Пути совершенствования законодательства о недвижимом
имуществе [Vitryansky V.V. Ways to Improve Legislation on Real Estate] (in Russian)
// Economy and Law. 2003. No. 6.
Гудочкова Е.Г. От принципа «единой судьбы земельных участков
и расположенных на них объектов» к концепции единого объекта [Gudochkova E.G.
From the Principle of “a Single Fate of Land Plots and Units Located on Them” to
the Concept of a Sole Unit] (in Russian) // Property Relations in the Russian Federation.
2010. No. 9.
Гусева М.А. Некоторые спорные вопросы о едином объекте недвижимости
[Guseva M.A. Some Controversial Issues on a Sole Property Unit] (in Russian) //
Business, Management and Law. 2013. No. 1.
Малков С.П. Международное космическое право: Учебное пособие [Malkov S.P.
International Space Law: Study Guide] (in Russian). St. Petersburg: SUAI, 2002.
Саватье Р. Теория обязательств [Savatier R. Theory of Obligations] (in Russian).
Moscow: Progress, 1972.
Скловский К.И. Собственность в гражданском праве [Sklovsky K.I. Property in
Civil Law] (in Russian). 5th ed. Moscow: Statut, 2010.
Фон Бар К. Для чего нужно понятие земельного участка (Grundstück) и что
это такое? О сложностях установления содержания понятия «вещь» в европей-
ском вещном праве [Von Bar С. Why Do We Need Grundstücke (Land Units), and
What Are They? On the Difficulties of Divining a European Concept of “Thing” in
Property Law] (in Russian) // Civil Law Review. 2018. No. 5.
Штоф А. Горное право. Сравнительное изложение горных законов, действу-
ющих в России и в главнейших горнопромышленных государствах Западной
Европы [Shtof A. Mountain Law. Comparative Presentation of the Mining Laws in
Force in Russia and in the Main Mining States of Western Europe] (in Russian). St.
Petersburg: Printing house of M.M. Stasyulevich, 1896.
Ball S.S. Division into Horizontal Strata of the Landspace Above the Surface //
Yale Law Journal. 1930. Vol. 39. No. 5.
Black’s Law Dictionary / Ed. by B.A. Garner. 10th ed. St. Paul, MN: Thomson West,
Committee of the Section of Real Property, Probate and Trust Law. Model Airspace
Act // Real Property, Probate and Trust Journal. 1973. Vol. 8. No. 3.
Ernald Borges K. BSc and MSc Theses on Three-Dimensional Property Units
and Ownership Apartments in Sweden // http://lup.lub.lu.se/search/ws/
Faure-Abbad M. La propriété d’un volume // https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-
Logan T.J. Carbon Down Under – Lessons from Australia: Two Recommendations
for Clarifying Subsurface Property Rights to Facilitate Onshore Geologic Carbon
Sequestration in the United States // San Diego International Law Journal.
2010. Vol. 11. No. 2.
March-Paschal S. W hat Is a Flying Freehold? // https://www.frettens.co.uk/site/
Ploeger H., van Velten A., Zevenbergen J. Real Property Law and Procedure in the
European Union: Report for the Netherlands // https://www.eui.eu/Documents/
Questionnaire 3D-Cadastres: status November 2010. France // http://www.
Sandberg H. Three-Dimensional Partition and Registration of Subsurface Land
Space // Israel Law Review. 2004. Vol. 37. No. 1.
Smith P.F. An Initial Assessment of English Commonholds // Stellenbosch Law
Review. 2005. Vol. 16. No. 3.
Stoter J.E. 3D Cadastre. PhD thesis. Delft, the Netherlands: Delft University of
Technology, 2004.
Stoter J.E. Needs, Possibilities and Constraints to Develop a 3D Cadastral Registration
System // https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/851b/6d09962537f4fb6580
Stoter J.E., Ploeger H.D. Multiple Use of Space: Current Practice of Registration
and Development of a 3D Cadastre // http://papers.cumincad.org/data/works/
Valstad T. 3D Cadastres in Europe // http://www.gdmc.nl/3DCadastres/
Valstad T. Developments of the 3D Cadastre in Norway // http://www.gdmc.
Valstad T. The Oslo Method – A Practical Approach to Register 3D Properties //
Wakker J.W., van der Molen P., Lemmen C. Land Registration and Cadastre in the
Netherlands, and the Role of Cadastral Boundaries: The Application of GPS Technology
in the Survey of Cadastral Boundaries // Journal of Geospatial Engineering.
2003. Vol. 5. No. 1.
Widener M.N. Local Regulating of Drone Activity in Lower Airspace // Boston
University Journal of Science & Technology Law. 2016. Vol. 22. No. 2.

Information about the author

Tretyakova D.V. (Moscow) – Master of Private Law (Russian School of Private
Law), Advocate of the Bar Association “Jurproject” (650066, Kemerovo, Pionersky
Boulv., 3, Office 307; e-mail: tretyakovadaria@gmail.com).