NULLITY OF TRANSACTIONS
UNDER THE CURRENT CIVIL LEGISLATION

​

V.S. EM,
Candidate of Legal Sciences, Associate Professor

​

DOI: 10.24031/1992-2043-2018-18-4-12-45

​

The article considers last amendments to Art. 168 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation
(nullity of illegal contracts) and their interpretation by the Plenum of the Supreme
Court of the Russian Federation of 23 June 2015 No. 25. The author analyzes the concepts
of public and third party’s interests and provisions of the Supreme Court’s Plenum.

Keywords: nullity; illegal transactions; public interest; Art. 168 of the Russian Civil
Code.

​

References

Amfiteatrov G.N. Prava na zhilye stroeniya i pol’zovanie zhilymi pomeshcheniyami
[Rights to Residential Buildings and Use of Living Quarters] (in Russian). Moscow,
1948.
Bagaev V.A. Pravovoe polozhenie davnostnogo vladel’tsa v anglijskom i rossijskom
prave [Legal Status of the Long-Time Owner in English and Russian Law] (in
Russian) // Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation.
2014. No. 1.
Bandurov D.N. Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya predprinimatel’stva i gosudarstvennoj
registratsii ego sub’ektov: Avtoref. dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk [Problems of the
Legal Regulation of Entrepreneurship and State Registration of Its Subjects: Synopsis
of a Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences] (in Russian). Stavropol, 2003.
Borzilo E.Yu. Antimonopol’nye riski predprinimatel’skoj deyatel’nosti: Nauchno-
prakticheskoe rukovodstvo [Antitrust Risks of Entrepreneurial Activity: Scientific
and Practical Guidance] (in Russian). Moscow, 2014.
Borzilo E.Yu. Ushchemlenie interesov tret’ikh lits kak kriterij antimonopol’nogo
narusheniya: tendentsii rossijskogo pravoprimeneniya [Impairment of Interests of
Third Parties as a Criterion of Antimonopoly Violation: The Tendency of Russian
Law Enforcement] (in Russian) // Advocate. 2013. No. 6.
Borzilo E.Yu. Voprosy nedejstvitel’nosti sdelok, sovershennykh s narusheniem
antimonopol’nogo zakonodatel’stva [Questions of Invalidity of Transactions Committed
in Violation of the Antimonopoly Legislation] (in Russian) // Laws of Russia.
2014. No. 2.
Braginsky M.I., Vitryansky V.V. Dogovornoe pravo. Kn. 2: Dogovory o peredache
imushchestva [Contract Law. Book 2: Agreements on the Transfer of Property] (in
Russian). Moscow, 2003.
Braude I.L. Pravo na stroenie i sdelki po stroeniyam po sovetskomu grazhdanskomu
pravu [The Right to Structure and Transactions on Buildings under Soviet
Civil Law] (in Russian). 2nd ed. Moscow, 1954.
Burkova A. Zapreshchyonnyj posleduyushchij zalog teper’ dejstvitelen [The Forbidden
Subsequent Pledge is Now Valid] (in Russian) // Corporate Lawyer. 2010.
No. 3.
Chechot D.M. Sub’ektivnoe pravo i formy ego zashchity [Subjective Law and Forms
of Its Protection] (in Russian). St. Petersburg, 1968.
Cherepakhin B.B. K voprosu o chastnom i publichnom prave [On the Issue of Private
and Public Law] (in Russian) / Id. Trudy po grazhdanskomu pravu [Works on
Civil Law]. Moscow, 2001.
Dedov D.I. «Zolotaya aktsiya» i publichnye interesy [“Gold Share” and Public
Interests] (in Russian) // Lawyer. 2003. No. 9.
Dedov D.I. Realizatsiya printsipa sorazmernosti v pravovom regulirovanii
predprinimatel’skoj deyatel’nosti: Avtoref. dis. … dokt. yurid. nauk [Realization of the
Principle of Proportionality in the Legal Regulation of Entrepreneurial Activity: Synopsis
of a Thesis for a Doctor Degree in Law Sciences] (in Russian). Moscow, 2005.
Egorov A.V., Erokhova M.A., Shirvindt A.M. Obobshchenie primeneniya arbitrazhnymi
sudami norm GK RF o veshchno-pravovykh sposobakh zashchity prava
[Generalization of the Application of the Norms of the Civil Code on the Real-Legal
Means of Protecting the Law by Arbitration Courts] (in Russian) // Civil Law
Review. 2007. No. 4.
Egorov N.D. Ponyatie grazhdanskogo prava [The Concept of Civil Law] (in Russian)
// Civil Law Review. 2012. No. 4.
Egorova M.A. Sovremennye podkhody k pravovomu regulirovaniyu soglasovannykh
dejstvij hozyajstvuyushchikh sub’ektov tovarnykh rynkov [Modern Approaches
to the Legal Regulation of Concerted Actions of Economic Entities of Commodity
Markets] (in Russian) // Competition Law. 2012. No. 2.
Gadzhiev G.A. Pravovye pozitsii Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF o garantiyakh prava
chastnoj sobstvennosti pri prinuditel’nom otchuzhdenii imushchestva dlya gosudarstvennykh
nuzhd [Legal Positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian
Federation on Guarantees of the Right of Private Property in Case of Compulsory
Acquisition of Property for State Needs] (in Russian) // Legislation. 2008. No. 1.
Gavrilov D.A. Pravovaya zashchita ot nedobrosovestnoj konkurentsii v sfere
isklyuchitel’nykh prav na sredstva individualizatsii i inye ob’ekty promyshlennoj
sobstvennosti [Legal Protection Against Unfair Competition in the Sphere of Exclusive
Rights to Means of Individualization and Other Objects of Industrial Property]
(in Russian). Moscow, 2014.
Gnitsevich K.V. Preddogovornaya otvetstvennost’ v rossijskom grazhdanskom
prave (culpa in contrahendo) [Pre-Contractual Liability in Russian Civil Law (culpa in contrahendo)] (in Russian) // Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of
the Russian Federation. 2009. No. 3.
Grazhdanskij kodeks Rossijskoj Federatsii. Arenda. Naem zhilogo pomeshcheniya:
Postatejnyj kommentarij k glavam 34 i 35 [The Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
Rent. Residential Lease: A Commentary to Chapters 34 and 35] (in Russian) /
Ed. by P.V. Krasheninnikov. Moscow, 2014.
Grazhdanskij kodeks Rossijskoj Federatsii. Postatejnyj kommentarij k glavam 6–
12 [The Civil Code of the Russian Federation. A Commentary to Chapters 6–12] (in
Russian) / Ed. by L.V. Sannikova. Moscow, 2014.
Grazhdanskij kodeks Rossijskoj Federatsii: Zalog. Peremena lits v obyazatel’stve.
Postatejnyj kommentarij k § 3 glavy 23 i glave 24 [The Civil Code of the Russian Federation:
Pledge. Substitution of Parties in an Obligation. A Commentary to Chapter 3,
§ 3 and Chapter 24] (in Russian) / Ed. by P.V. Krasheninnikov. Moscow, 2014.
Grazhdanskoe pravo: Uchebnik. V 4 t. [Civil Law: Textbook. In 4 vol.] (in Russian)
/ Ed. by E.A. Sukhanov. Vol. 1. 2nd ed. Moscow, 2004.
Grazhdanskoe pravo: Uchebnik. V 4 t. [Civil Law: Textbook. In 4 vol.] (in Russian)
/ Ed. by E.A. Sukhanov. Vol. 2. 3rd ed. Moscow, 2005.
Gribanov V.P. Interes v grazhdanskom prave [Interest in Civil Law] (in Russian) //
Soviet State and Law. 1967. No. 1.
Gribanov V.P. Osushchestvlenie i zashchita grazhdanskikh prav [Exercitation and
Protection of Civil Rights] (in Russian). Moscow, 2000.
Gukasyan R.E. Lichnye i obshchestvennye interesy v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve
[Personal and Public Interests in Civil Proceedings] (in Russian) // Sb. st.
k 50-letiyu E.A. Krasheninnikova [Collection of Articles to the 50th Anniversary of
E.A. Krasheninnikov]. Yaroslavl, 2001.
Gukasyan R.E. Problema interesov v sovetskom grazhdanskom protsessual’nom
prave [The Problem of Interests in Soviet Civil Procedural Law] (in Russian). Saratov,
1970.
Gurvich M.A. Grazhdanskie protsessual’nye pravootnosheniya i protsessual’nye
dejstviya [Civil Procedural Legal Relations and Procedural Actions] (in Russian) //
Trudy VYUZI [Proceedings of the All-Union Correspondence Institute of Law].
Moscow, 1965. Vol. 3.
Gushchin V.V., Kirpichev A.E. Nedejstvitel’nost’ gosudarstvennykh i munitsipal’nykh
kontraktov [Invalidity of State and Municipal Contracts] (in Russian) // Laws of Russia.
2014. No. 5.
Guterman A.E. Pravovaya priroda i soderzhanie kartel’nykh soglashenij [The Legal
Nature and Content of Cartel Agreements] (in Russian) // Lawyer. 2014. No. 2.
Gutnikov O.V. Nedejstvitel’nye sdelki v grazhdanskom prave: Teoriya i praktika
osparivaniya [Invalid Transactions in Civil Law: Theory and Practice of Challenging]
(in Russian). Moscow, 2003.
Ilyin I.A. Obshchee uchenie o prave i gosudarstve [General Doctrine of Law and
the State] (in Russian). Moscow, 2006.
Ilyushikhin I.N. Kommentarij k Federal’nomu zakonu ot 18 iyulya 2005 g.
№ 87-FZ «O vnesenii izmenenij v Federal’nyj zakon «Ob oborote zemel’ sel’skokhozyajstvennogo
naznacheniya» i Federal’nyj zakon «O zemleustrojstve»» [A Commentary
to Federal Law No. 87-FZ of 18 July 2005 “On Amendments to the Federal
Law ‘On the Turnover of Agricultural Land’ and the Federal Law ‘On Land Management’”]
(in Russian) // Law and Economics. 2005. No. 10.
Ilyushina M.N. Reforma otechestvennogo grazhdanskogo zakonodatel’stva
o nedejstvitel’nosti sdelok: tseli i aktual’noe sostoyanie [Reform of the Domestic
Civil Legislation on the Invalidity of Transactions: Goals and Current Status] (in
Russian) // Laws of Russia. 2014. No. 5.
Kalinkin A. Ubytki, a ne restitutsiya [Losses, Not Restitution] (in Russian) // ezh-
Lawyer. 2015. No. 31.
Kasso L.A. Russkoe pozemel’noe pravo [Russian Land Law] (in Russian). Moscow,
1906.
Kazachkova Z.M. Sootnoshenie konkurentnogo i antimonopol’nogo prava
v aspekte universal’nykh tsennostej konkurentsii i interesov potrebitelej: sravnitel’nyj
analiz [Correlation of Competitive and Antimonopoly Law in the Aspect of Universal
Values of Competition and Consumer Interests: Comparative Analysis] (in Russian)
// Competition Law. 2011. No. 2.
Khaskelberg B.L., Rovny V.V. Perekhod vymorochnogo nasledstva k publichnomu
obrazovaniyu [Transition of the Escheat Inheritance to Public Education] (in Russian)
// Inheritance Law. 2012. Nos. 1–4.
Klein N.I. Zashchita publichnogo pravoporyadka i grazhdanskikh prav pri narushenii
antimonopol’nogo zakonodatel’stva [Protection of Public Law and Civil
Rights in Case of Violation of the Antimonopoly Legislation] (in Russian) // Law.
2008. No. 2.
Kommentarij k Federal’nomu zakonu «O zashchite konkurentsii» (postatejnyj)
[A Commentary to the Federal Law “On Protection of Competition” (itemized)] (in
Russian) / Ed. by V.F. Popondopulo, D.A. Petrov. Moscow, 2013.
Konceptsiya razvitiya grazhdanskogo zakonodatel’stva Rossijskoj Federatsii [Concept
of Development of the Civil Legislation of the Russian Federation] (in Russian).
Moscow, 2009.
Koryakin V.M., Voropaev D.A. Voprosy nedejstvitel’nosti grazhdansko-pravovykh
sdelok, sovershennykh s priznakami korruptsii [Questions of Invalidity of Civil Law
Transactions Committed with Signs of Corruption] (in Russian) // Russian Justice.
2014. No. 6.
Litovkin V.N. Obmanutye dol’shchiki, ili investitsii grazhdan v zhilishchnoe
stroitel’stvo nuzhdayutsya v sovershenstvovanii [Defrauded Co-investors, or Investments
of Citizens in Housing Construction Need to Be Improved] (in Russian) //
Grazhdanskoe pravo i sovremennost’: Sb. st. pamyati M.I. Braginskogo [Civil Law and
Modernity: Collection of Articles in Memory of M.I. Braginsky] / Ed. by V.N. Litovkin,
K.B. Yaroshenko. Moscow, 2013.
Malko A.V., Subochev V.V., Sheriev А.М. Prava, svobody i zakonnye interesy: problemy
yuridicheskogo obespecheniya [Rights, Freedoms and Legal Interests: Problems
of Legal Support] (in Russian). Moscow, 2010.
Misnik G.A., Misnik N.N. Publichnye i chastnye interesy v ekologicheskom prave
[Public and Private Interests in Environmental Law] (in Russian) // State and Law.
2006. No. 2.
Molotnikov A.E., Tekutyev D.I. Pravovye problemy uchastiya gosudarstva v aktsionernykh
obshchestvakh [Legal Problems of State Participation in Joint-Stock Companies]
(in Russian) // Property Relations in the Russian Federation. 2012. No. 7.
Muromtsev S.A. Opredelenie i osnovnoe razdelenie prava [Definition and Basic
Division of Law] (in Russian). 2nd ed. St. Petersburg, 2004.
Petrukhin M.V. Dogovor uchastiya v dolevom stroitel’stve ob’ektov nedvizhimosti:
problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya [The Contract of Participation in the Joint Construction
of Real Estate: Problems of Legal Regulation] (in Russian). Moscow, 2012.
Pravo sobstvennosti: aktual’nye problemy [Ownership: Current Problems] (in
Russian) / Ed. by V.N. Litovkin, E.A. Sukhanov, V.V. Chubarov. Moscow, 2008.
Rabinovich N.V. Nedejstvitel’nost’ sdelok i ee posledstviya [Invalidity of Transactions
and Its Consequences] (in Russian). St. Petersburg, 1960.
Rego A., Tolstobrov S. Problemy osparivaniya sdelok, sovershennykh s narusheniem
antimonopol’nogo zakonodatel’stva [Problems of Challenging Transactions
Committed in Violation of the Antimonopoly Legislation] (in Russian) // Corporate
Lawyer. 2010. No. 9.
Romashov R.A. Sub’ektivnyj interes kak osnovanie kontseptsii chastnogo prava [Subjective
Interest as the Basis of the Concept of Private Law] (in Russian) // Aktual’nye
problemy grazhdanskogo prava i protsessa: Sb. mat. Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf.
Vyp. 1 [Actual Problems of Civil Law and Procedure: Collection of Materials of the
International Scientific and Practical Conference. Issue 1] / Ed. by D.Kh. Valeev,
M.Yu. Chelyshev. Moscow, 2006.
Rossijskoe grazhdanskoe pravo: Uchebnik. V 2 t. [Russian Civil Law: Textbook.
In 2 vol.] (in Russian) / Ed. by E.A. Sukhanov. Vol. 1. 2nd ed. Moscow, 2011.
Rumyantsev F.P. Osobennosti dogovora kupli-prodazhi zemel’nykh uchastkov
sel’skokhozyajstvennogo naznacheniya [Features of the Contract of Sale and Purchase
of Agricultural Land Plots] (in Russian) // Journal of Russian Law. 2013. No. 8.
Sadikov O.N. Grazhdansko-pravovye kategorii v publichnom prave [Civil Law
Categories in Public Law] (in Russian) // Journal of Russian Law. 2011. No. 9.
Samsonova M.V. Zashchita interesov v grazhdanskom sudoproizvodstve (na primere del o zashchite prav potrebitelej) [Protection of Interests in Civil Legal Proceedings (on the Example of Cases on Protection of Consumers’ Rights)] (in Russian) //
Laws of Russia: Experience, Analysis, Practice. 2012. No. 9.
Serova O.A. Eshche raz o gosudarstvennykh korporatsiyakh ili o novykh zadachakh
nauchnykh issledovanij [Once Again on State Corporations or on New Tasks
of Scientific Research] (in Russian) // Perm University Herald. Juridical Sciences.
2013. No. 4.
Shayo A. Obshchestvennyj interes i iz’yatie imushchestva [Public Interest and Seizure
of Property] (in Russian) // Konstitutsionno-pravovye osnovy sobstvennosti
i predprinimatel’stva: problemy realizatsii: Sb. dokladov [Constitutional and Legal
Foundations of Property and Entrepreneurship: Implementation Problems: Collection
of Reports]. Moscow, 2010.
Shershenevich G.F. Uchebnik russkogo grazhdanskogo prava [Textbook of Russian
Civil Law] (in Russian). Moscow, 1995.
Shestakova N.D. Nedejstvitel’nost’ sdelok [Invalidity of Transactions] (in Russian).
St. Petersburg, 2001.
Shevtsov S.G. Obosnovanie nedejstvitel’nosti sdelok neupravomochennykh lits
po rasporyazheniyu chuzhim imushchestvom [The Substantiation of Invalidity of
Transactions of Unauthorized Persons on Disposal of Another’s Property] (in Russian)
// Arbitration Practice. 2003. No. 1.
Sitdikova R.I. Obespechenie chastnykh, obshchestvennykh i publichnykh interesov
avtorskim pravom [Providing Private and Public Interests with Copyright] (in
Russian). Moscow, 2013.
Sklovsky K., Smirnova M. Institut preimushchestvennoj pokupki v rossijskom
i zarubezhnom prave [The Institute of Preferential Purchase in Russian and Foreign
Law] (in Russian) // Economics and Law. 2003. Nos. 10, 11.
Sklovsky K.I. O dejstvitel’nosti prodazhi chuzhogo imushchestva [On the Validity
of the Sale of Other People’s Property] (in Russian) // Bulletin of the Supreme
Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation. 2003. No. 9.
Sklovsky K.I. Sdelka i ee dejstvie [Transaction and Its Operation] (in Russian) //
Civil Law Review. 2012. No. 3.
Sklovsky K.I. Sobstvennost’ v grazhdanskom prave [Property in Civil Law] (in
Russian). 5th ed. Moscow, 2010.
Skrypnik D.O. O nedejstvitel’nosti sdelki, narushayushchej trebovaniya zakona ili
inogo pravovogo akta [On the Invalidity of a Transaction That Violates the Requirements
of the Law or Other Legal Act] (in Russian) // ezh-Lawyer. 2013. No. 50.
Slovar’ inostrannykh slov [Dictionary of Foreign Words] (in Russian). Moscow,
1955.
Slyshchenkov V.A. O nichtozhnosti zaklyuchennogo neupravomochennym
otchuzhdatelem dogovora kupli-prodazhi chuzhoj veshchi [On the Insignificance
of a Contract of Purchase and Sale of a Strange Thing Concluded by an Unauthorized
Alienator] (in Russian) // Lawyer. 2001. No. 1.
Subochev V.V. Zakonnye interesy [Legitimate Interests] (in Russian) / Ed. by
A.V. Malko. Moscow, 2008.
Sukhanov E.A. Gosudarstvennye yuridicheskie litsa v sovremennom rossijskom
prave [State Legal Entities in Modern Russian Law] (in Russian) // Grazhdanskoe
pravo i sovremennost’: Sb. st. pamyati M.I. Braginskogo [Civil Law and Modernity:
Collection of Articles in Memory of M.I. Braginsky] / Ed. by V.N. Litovkin,
K.B. Yaroshenko. Moscow, 2013.
Sukhanov E.A. O yuridicheskikh litsakh publichnogo prava [On Legal Entities of
Public Law] (in Russian) // Civil Law Review. 2011. No. 2.
Svirin Yu.A. Problemy pravovogo regulirovaniya dogovora postavki produktov
pitaniya [Problems of Legal Regulation of the Contract for the Supply of Food Products]
(in Russian) // Attorney. 2013. No. 12.
Tarkhov V.A. Nekotorye voprosy okhrany imushchestvennykh prav trudyashchihsya
po sovetskomu grazhdanskomu zakonodatel’stvu [Some Issues of Protection
of Workers’ Property Rights under Soviet Civil Law] (in Russian) // Uch. tr.
Saratovskogo yuridicheskogo instituta [Scientific Notes of the Saratov Law Institute].
Saratov, 1969. Issue 2.
Timofeev P. Zapreshchyon, no dejstvitelen [Prohibited, But Valid] (in Russian) //
ezh-Lawyer. 2010. No. 6.
Tserkovnikov M.A. Nedejstvitel’nost’ sdelok v novykh raz’yasneniyakh Verkhovnogo
Suda RF [Invalidity of Transactions in the New Clarifications of the Supreme
Court of the Russian Federation] (in Russian) // Law. 2015. No. 9.
Tserkovnikov M.A. Osnovanie otvetstvennosti prodavtsa za iz’yatie tovara u pokupatelya
[The Basis of the Seller’s Responsibility for the Withdrawal of the Goods
from the Buyer] (in Russian) // Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the
Russian Federation. 2013. No. 11.
Tserkovnikov M.A. Otvetstvennost’ prodavtsa v sluchae iz’yatiya tovara u pokupatelya
[Responsibility of the Seller in Case of Withdrawal of the Goods from the
Buyer] (in Russian). Moscow, 2016.
Tuzov D.O. Eshche raz o dejstvitel’nosti obyazatel’stvennogo dogovora prodazhi,
zaklyuchennogo neupravomochennym litsom [Once Again on the Validity of
the Obligation Contract of Sale Concluded by an Unauthorized Person] (in Russian)
// Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation. 2007.
No. 12.
Tuzov D.O. Nichtozhnost’ i osporimost’ sdelok: klassicheskaya doktrina i problemy
rossijskoj tsivilistiki [The Insignificance and Controversy of Transactions: The
Classical Doctrine and Problems of Russian Civil Law] (in Russian) // Tsivilisticheskie
zapiski: Mezhvuzovskij sb. nauch. tr. Vyp. 2 [Civil Notes: Intercollegiate
Collection of Scientific Proceedings. Issue 2]. Moscow; Yekaterinburg, 2002.
Tuzov D.O. Nichtozhnost’ sdelok, narushayushchikh trebovaniya zakona ili inogo
pravovogo akta (nekotorye razmyshleniya o novoj redaktsii st. 168 GK RF) [The
Insignificance of Transactions That Violate the Requirements of the Law or Other
Legal Act (Some Reflections on the New Edition of Article 168 of the Civil Code)]
(in Russian) // Sb. st. pamyati E.A. Krasheninnikova [Collection of Articles in Memory
of E.A. Krasheninnikov] / Ed. by A.P. Sergeev. Yaroslavl, 2014.
Tuzov D.O. Prodazha chuzhogo i problema zashchity dobrosovestnogo priobretatelya
v rossijskom grazhdanskom prave (okonchanie) [The Sale of Another
and the Problem of Protecting a Bona Fide Purchaser in Russian Civil Law (finale)]
(in Russian) // Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation.
2007. No. 2.
Tuzov D.O. Prodazha imushchestva neupravomochennym litsom i iskovaya
davnost’ pri primenenii posledstvij nedejstvitel’nosti sdelki [Sale of Property by an
Unauthorized Person and Limitation of Actions in Case of Application of Consequences
of Invalidity of the Transaction] (in Russian) // Herald of Economic Justice
of the Russian Federation. 2015. No. 4.
Venetsianov M.V. Ekspropriatsiya s tochki zreniya grazhdanskogo prava [Expropriation
from the Point of View of Civil Law] (in Russian). Kazan, 1891.
Verbina O.L. Prava uchastnikov dolevogo stroitel’stva zhil’ya v Rossijskoj Federatsii:
problemy realizatsii [Rights of Participants in the Joint Construction of Housing
in the Russian Federation: Implementation Problems] (in Russian) // Legal
Issues of Real Estate. 2014. No. 1.
Vitruk N.V. Obshchaya teoriya pravovogo polozheniya lichnosti [General Theory
of the Legal Position of the Individual] (in Russian). Moscow, 2008.
Vorobyeva E.A. Pravovoe regulirovanie sdelok, trebuyushchikh soglasiya (odobreniya)
tret’ikh lits [Legal Regulation of Transactions Requiring Consent (Approval)
of Third Parties] (in Russian) // Journal of Russian Law. 2012. No. 3.
Yakovlev V.F. O chastnom i publichnom prave v pravovoj sisteme Rossii: Vystuplenie
na nauchnoj konferentsii v I nstitute gosudarstva i prava Rossijskoj akademii
nauk (Moskva, 31 marta 2000 g.) [On Private and Public Law in the Legal System
of Russia: Speech at a Scientific Conference at the Institute of State and Law of the
Russian Academy of Sciences (Moscow, 31 March 2000)] (in Russian) / Id. Pravovoe
gosudarstvo: voprosy formirovaniya [The Rule of Law: Issues of Formation]. Moscow,
2012.
Yatsenko Т.S. Mekhanizm protivodejstviya antisotsial’nomu povedeniyu uchastnikov
oborota v dejstvuyushchem grazhdanskom zakonodatel’stve [The Mechanism
of Counteracting the Antisocial Behavior of the Participants of the Turnover in the
Current Civil Legislation] (in Russian) // Problemy razvitiya chastnogo prava: Sb.
st. k yubileyu V.S. Ema [Problems of the Development of Private Law: Collection of
Articles to the Anniversary of V.S. Em] / Ed. by E.A. Sukhanov, N.V. Kozlov. Moscow,
2011.
Yumashev Yu.M., Postnikova E.V. Ekonomicheskoe pravo Evropejskogo soyuza
[Economic Law of the European Union] (in Russian). Moscow, 2014.
Zalog, bankovskaya garantiya i drugie sposoby obespecheniya ispolneniya
obyazatel’stv: Postatejnyj kommentarij glavy 23 Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossijskoj
Federatsii [Pledge, Bank Guarantee and Other Ways of Securing the Fulfillment of
Obligations: A Commentary to Chapter 23 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]
(in Russian) / Ed. by P.V. Krasheninnikov, B.M. Gongalo. Moscow, 2010.
Zdravomyslov A.G. Potrebnosti. Interesy. Tsennosti [Needs. Interests. Values] (in
Russian). Moscow, 1986.
Zhuzhzhalov M.B. Priroda otvetstvennosti za ehviktsiyu [The Nature of Responsibility
for Eviction] (in Russian) // Civil Law Review. 2014. No. 6.

Information about the author

​