LOSS AND IMMATERIAL DAMAGE

Yu.E. MONASTYRSKY,
Candidate of Legal Sciences

DOI: 10.24031/1992-2043-2019-19-2-113-132

This publication is posted to discuss the comparative features of such important legal
categories as non-material injury in correlation with damages. In addition to reviewing
several doctrinal judgments about them, the findings of higher courts and the European
approaches, the author also focuses on question of relationship between concepts of
moral and reputational impact, noting here that not all the identified significance
commonly used in the doctrine correspond to strict legislative terminology. For example,
information injurious to honor, dignity, business reputation does not cause, except
moral, harm as such, but associated with the appearance of damages. It seems to be
the first time proposed to evaluate the thesis that they can be recovered instead of any
non-pecuniary damage. The practice of compensation simply for mental illness, etc.
is extremely rare with nominal value of recoveries, in our view, damages, due to the
interpretation of Article 1082 of the Civil Code, can be collected due to misery, ailments,
suffering, anxiety etc. Of course, if damages occurred or are to be born, but are not just
expected, as the loss of profit is that which could have been received.


Keywords: damages; immaterial harm.

References

Belyatskin S.A. Vozmeshchenie moral’nogo (neimushchestvennogo) vreda [Compensation
of Moral (Immaterial) Damage]. St. Petersburg, 1913.
Egorov V.V. Vzyskanie ubytkov v forme upushchennoj vygody: praktika Еvropejskogo
suda po pravam cheloveka i arbitrazhnykh sudov RF [Recovery of Damages in
the Form of Lost Profits: The Practice of the European Court of Human Rights and the
Arbitration Courts of the Russian Federation] // Arbitration Practice. 2009. No. 8.
Erdelevsky A.M. O moral’nom i «reputatsionnom» vrede v svete izmenenij Grazhdanskogo
kodeksa RF [On Moral and “Reputational” Damage in the Light of Changes
to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation] // Economy and Law. 2017. No. 2.
Farber I.E. Svoboda i prava cheloveka v Sovetskom gosudarstve [Freedom and
Human Rights in the Soviet State]. Saratov, 1974.
Gavrilov E.V. Evolyutsioniruyushchij kharakter praktiki Еvropejskogo suda po
pravam cheloveka o kompensatsii nematerial’nogo vreda yuridicheskim litsam [The
Evolving Nature of the Practice of the European Court of Human Rights on the
Compensation of Immaterial Damage to Legal Entities] // Arbitration Disputes.
2018. No. 2.
Gavrilov E.V. Nasledie praktiki VAS RF i novejshaya praktika VS RF o kompensatsii
nematerial’nogo (reputatsionnogo) vreda yuridicheskim litsam [The Legacy
of the Practice of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation and the
Newest Practice of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on the Compensation
of Immaterial (Reputational) Damage to Legal Entities] // Arbitration Disputes.
2017. No. 4.
Gloov D.H. Shtrafnye ubytki v potrebitel’skom prave [Penalties in Consumer
Law] // Dogovory i obyazatel’stva: Sbornik rabot vypusknikov Rossijskoj shkoly
chastnogo prava pri Issledovatel’skom tsentre chastnogo prava imeni S.S. Alekseeva
pri Prezidente RF [Contracts and Obligations: Collection of Works by Graduates
of the Russian School of Private Law at the Alekseev Private Law Research Center
Under the President of the Russian Federation] / Comp. and ed. by A.V. Egorov.
Vol. 3. Moscow, 2018.
Kirakosyan S.A., Emelina E.S. Reputatsionnyj vred yuridicheskogo litsa: osobennosti
dokazyvaniya i sudebnaya praktika [Reputational Damage of a L egal Entity: Features
of Evidence and Judicial Practice] // Bulletin of Arbitration Practice. 2017. No. 2.
Magaziner Ya.M. Obshchaya teoriya prava na osnove sovetskogo zakonodatel’stva
[General Theory of Law Based on the Soviet Legislation] / Magaziner Ya.M. Izbrannye
trudy po obshchej teorii prava [Selected Works on the General Theory of Law] /
Ed. by A.K. Kravtsov. St. Petersburg, 2006.
Malein N.S. Okhrana prav lichnosti sovetskim zakonodatel’stvom [The Protection
of Individual Rights by Soviet Law]. Moscow, 1985.
Parygina N.N. Zashchita prava na delovuyu reputatsiyu yuridicheskikh lits
i individual’nykh predprinimatelej po grazhdanskomu zakonodatel’stvu Rossijskoj
Federatsii: Dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Protection of the Right to Business Reputation
of Legal Entities and Individual Entrepreneurs Under the Civil Legislation of the
Russian Federation: Thesis for a Candidate Degree in Law Sciences]. Omsk, 2017.
Sebok A.J. Punitive Damages in the United States // Punitive Damages: Common
Law and Civil Law Perspectives (= Tort and Insurance Law. Vol. 25) / H. Koziol,
V. Wilcox (eds.). Springer, 2009.
Sklovsky K.I. Povsednevnaya tsivilistika [Everyday Civil Law]. Moscow, 2017.
Smirnov V.T., Sobchak A.A. Obshchee uchenie o deliktnykh obyazatel’stvakh
v sovetskom grazhdanskom prave: Uchebnoe posobie [The General Theory of Tort
Obligations in Soviet Civil Law: Textbook]. Leningrad, 1983.
Ulbashev A.Kh. Osushchestvlenie i zashchita lichnykh prav [The Exercise and
Protection of Personal Rights] // Legislation. 2017. No. 9.
Vorobev A.V. Institut kompensatsii moral’nogo vreda v rossijskom grazhdanskom
prave [Institute of Compensation of Moral Damage in Russian Civil Law]. St.
Petersburg, 2008.
Yagelnitsky A.A. K voprosu o nerazryvnoj svyazi prava s lichnost’yu: preemstvo
v prave trebovat’ kompensatsii moral’nogo vreda i vreda, prichinyonnogo zhizni ili
zdorov’yu [On the Inextricable Relationship of Law with the Individual: Succession
in the Right to Demand Compensation for Moral Damage and Damage Caused to
Life or Health] // Civil Law Review. 2013. Vol. 13. No. 2.


Information about the author

Monastyrsky Yu.E. (Moscow) – Candidate of Legal Sciences (e-mail: monastyrsky@
mzs.ru).

Наши партнеры

Our partners

unnamed.png
Юстина.png
логотип РС серый фон.png

Copyright © 2006-2019 

Вестник гражданского права. Все права защищены. 
«ИД В. Ема»: 119454, Москва, ул. Лобачевского, 92, корп. 2

Civil law review. All rights reserved.

«ID V.Ema»: 119454, Moscow, ul. Lobachevsky, 92, building. 2